Every time one of my kids has a birthday I visit one of the major toy retailers and go through the same process. I wander the endless aisles becoming more and more confused and dazed. My feelings move from bewilderment, to frustration and finally to rage!
So much plastic, such high price tags! I end up leaving, purchasing nothing and find myself at our local educational toy shop - browsing beautifully crafted toys, designed to encourage a child’s imagination, and built to last.
I just returned from shopping for Big Sis’ birthday and it was no different! The word that kept springing to mind as I worked myself into a fury was “cynical”. Yes, the toys were cynical - like some kind of parody of childhood, put together with the cheapest materials and without care, in the cheapest labor markets available. I got as far as the Bratz shelf before I’d had enough.
I should state here, for the record, that I am not a Barbie hater. I preferred the Malibu Stacey designed by Lisa Simpson, but I don’t think it matters that much. Kids are far to smart to take their role model from one plastic doll. However, those Bratz dolls, those heinous little tarts, they are another story!
Gazing at the shelf I almost expected to see a tiny little cocaine mirror and purse, what’s next, a tiny pink Ferrari with a little police officers to arrest the party girl for DUI? An attorney dressed for court to bribe her out of prison? These dolls resemble the kinds of kids I don’t want Big Sis hanging out with in High School, so why give her the plastic versions to play with as a preschooler?
Bratz is not just designed to ignite the consumerist juices of the average 4 year old (though clever accessories and major marketing budget assure this), they themselves physically represent the little consumers the marketers hope our kids will grow into. Kids get to role play empty, meaningless, sad lives with lots of bling, lip gloss and clothes. So its double jeopardy, get your kids addicted to collecting all this plastic for ugly little dolls. The ugly little dolls themselves parodying the real behaviour of lots of ugly adults in our post modernist, consumerist world!
So what did I buy in the educational toy shop? An old fashioned flower press. Big Sis loves picking flowers and with Spring and the new baby just around the corner I have these mental fantasies of sitting on a large picnic rug, baby at my breast, Little Bro pottering nearby as Big Sis and I press flowers and discuss all that is natural and magical.
The truth is, educational toyshops fire my imagination! Then again, it could be the pregnancy hormones! But what’s wrong with that - Big Sis doesn’t know who Bratz is yet - and I’m not going to be the one to introduce them!
consumerism, dolls, flower press, Flowers, imagination, kids gifts

July 29th, 2007 at 1:23 pm
And now their making a movie. SO why not just make a MEAN GIRLS 2? That’s all it is really.
July 29th, 2007 at 1:31 pm
A movie? Oh well - at least Big Sis is still too little to want to go and see it? Maybe the whole phenomenon will have blown over by the time she gets ‘interested’?
July 29th, 2007 at 7:36 pm
Here, here!! I agree wholeheartedly! The Bratz dolls represent everything I DON’T want my daughter to be!
July 29th, 2007 at 10:26 pm
I dont like the bratz dolls either. I will not buy them. When im shopping for presents i like to find things that make kids do something, watercolor paints and paper, latchhook kits, sculpture painting, learn to knit…course these are older kid gifts, but there is something out there for everyone.
July 30th, 2007 at 2:18 am
I prefer the educational stores, too. I always spend a little too much money there!
July 30th, 2007 at 2:43 am
I agree with you about “Bratz” even wrote a post on my site about “Barbies and Bratz” they just don’t project the image of a successful female and as Mom to 3 daughters I am very conscious of “Successful Females”!
July 30th, 2007 at 7:13 am
The other place for bad role models is “video hits” type shows. Some of the images of women there, that are considered mainstream, astound me! But that’s the subject of another post I think!
August 2nd, 2007 at 2:54 am
Amen! We’ve banned Bratz from our house for those exact same reasons. I don’t know why toy manufacturers (and clothing manufacturs, but that’s another post) want to sexualize our young daughters. And I loved the line from your post: “These dolls resemble the kinds of kids I don’t want Big Sis hanging out with in High School, so why give her the plastic versions to play with as a preschooler?”
Thanks!
August 2nd, 2007 at 4:31 am
This is what happened when the coach told me the name of my daughter’s soccer team was The Bratz.
http://traceesioux.blogspot.com/2007/02/go-bratz-go.html
Tracee Sioux
So Sioux Me
Empower Your Self
Empower Your Daughter
http://www.sosiouxme.com
BlogFabulous
http://www.blogfabulous.com
August 2nd, 2007 at 11:24 pm
I never bought Bratz, but my 11 year-old has something like 15 of them she’s rec’d as gifts over the years. Since she’s older, we have talked about all of the above and she “gets” it — but I wouldn’t want my 4 year-old to have them. All of the Barbies are always nekkid which is worse than the clothing, anyway.
August 27th, 2007 at 7:56 pm
[…] may remember my post about shopping at an educational toy shop for Big Sis’ birthday. Well, it appears that while […]